Sunday, October 17, 2010

TorahBytes: The Akedah (Va-Yera)

After these things God tested Abraham and said to him, "Abraham!" And he said, "Here am I." He said, "Take your son, your only son Isaac, whom you love, and go to the land of Moriah, and offer him there as a burnt offering on one of the mountains of which I shall tell you." (Bereshit / Genesis 22:1, 2; ESV)

The "Akedah" or "Binding" of Isaac is one of the most difficult, troubling, and wonderful stories in the whole Bible. Thinking about this passage again this year, I struggled over whether it's about God commanding Abraham to sacrifice his son or God telling him not to. I know that in one sense God said both things, but if God didn't stop him, we would not be talking about this today. If Abraham would have just believed he was supposed to sacrifice his son and gone through with it, the story would be lost in the midst of the other innumerable horrific things people have done. It's only because God stopped him at the last moment that Abraham, not only went down in history, but became the Bible's primary model of true faithfulness to God.

But speaking of his faithfulness, wasn't it for Abraham's willingness in God's name to murder his son that God commended him (see 22:12)? That's true, but God didn't commend him for murdering Isaac, which he didn't do, but for not withholding Isaac from him. Remember it was never God's intention for Abraham to literally sacrifice Isaac. What God was looking for in Abraham was for a heart that was completely devoted to him.

You may be offended by the lack of moral struggle on Abraham's part. Many of us would expect a Shakespearean soliloquy by Abraham on his moral dilemma: "To kill or not to kill; that is the question!" But instead his struggle is found in the subtleties of the story. It's found in God's command "Take your son, your only son Isaac, whom you love…" (22:2; ESV) and in the extremely slow pace in which the story unfolds. Abraham's struggle is clear, but his thoughts are hidden from view. Only God knows what was happening in Abraham's heart as only God knows what is happening in your heart and mine.

Abraham staked his life on God and his promises to him. The same God who drew Abraham into the impossible by promising him and his barren wife a son in their old age - more than just a son, but the beginning of a great nation through whom blessing would come to the whole world - this same God seemed to be undermining his very own plan by recalling Isaac. Abraham was willing to completely trust God even when God appeared to be undermining his very own plan.

The life of genuine faith is not one that always makes sense. Knowing the Master of the Universe doesn't mean that we become philosophical experts and theological know-it-alls. Rather, to truly know God means to be drawn into a painful, seemingly contradictory tension in which we find ourselves struggling to know what's what. The reason for this is that God is at work to transform our natural inclination to put our trust into anything but him and his Word.

That doesn't mean that the goal of faith is to know nothing, to shut off our minds and blindly follow nonsensical spiritual promptings. If that were the case, Isaac would have been killed. On the contrary, nothing can compare with the depth and quality of knowledge that results from allowing ourselves to be transformed by the complexity of God's Word. It's what we do with this knowledge that matters.

God wants to teach us, to bless us with gifts with which to bless others. But it is so easy to turn God's blessings into idols. When we withhold God's blessings from him who gave them to us, then even his blessings can become tools of destruction to ourselves and to others. It is only as we follow Abraham's example, not withholding anything from God, trusting in him alone, not leaning on our own understanding, that we can become the people God has called us to be.

3 comments:

Melissa said...

Shalom Rabbi,
This is my first attempt at blogging about the Torahbytes; I always learn from your wisdom.
My question today is about your comment in the beginning of "if God had not stopped Abraham from sacrificing Isaac then the story would have gone down as another horrific tragedy of something unspeakable in history" or something to that affect.
What about Hebrews 11:19? Of course this is all speculation, but if we consider Heb. 11:19 and the sacrifice had been carried out, might not an outcome be like that of Lazarus?
Thanks for your thoughts,
Melissa

Anonymous said...

One key element of this story is that God knew exactly how it would play out in advance. Therefore the purpose of the story is to either record it for posterity (us) or to give Abraham something. What do you think Abraham gained through this?

Keren said...

Shalom,
Through the years, every time I come to this portion of scripture, I had pondered : What was Abraham going through emotionally to the very binding.
I must say that I recognize even more so as in the past that now, to me: as a meditation: Our Elohim would be in the place of Abraham, and Y'shua in the place of Yitzak for the future. I would have to say of the emotions our Father Elohim would have felt (that we can never fathom) when HIS SON was given, and offered up for the sins of the world.
What emotions would any human have if they had to give their son up and that their own hand would finish it? Oh, how much our Father, Creator loves us, How much Y'shua loves us as the Father loves us. Oh it is a pleasure to do your will oh Wonderous Creator!!
blessings, Keren